Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets – Review

Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets by J.K. Rowling

Published in 1998

Pages: 341

Genre: Fantasy, contemporary fantasy

“Not for the first time, an argument had broken out over breakfast at number four Privet Drive.”

While Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is a good follow-up to the first Harry Potter book, it fails to pack the same intensity as its predecessor. There isn’t much that is earth shattering as far as the plot goes and it often falls victim to familiar tropes from the first novel; however, there is some further character development and we are able to delve deeper into the connection between Harry and Voldemort.

Someone, or something, is petrifying (putting people into a comatose state, unlike the word’s use in the Gloria Gainor song “I Will Survive”) the students of Hogwarts and it is up to Harry to find the cause. In his attempts to solve the mystery, Harry’s insecurities really come to the fore. Those who read the first book will remember the scene with the Sorting Hat in which the he is nearly placed in the house of Slytherin. This plays a large part in the story when the Chamber of Secrets can only be opened by someone called Slytherin’s heir and Harry spends much of the tale wondering if it might be him.

Much of the evidence points in his direction. Some of the early (At first I was afraid, I was) petrified victims were people that Harry had gotten upset with shortly before they were found and his ability to speak to snakes, known as Parseltongue, is a characteristic that the founder of Slytherin also shared. We see Harry struggle with this knowledge for much of the book as he tries to unravel the mystery of the Chamber. He is a young boy trying to find his place in this magical world that is still so new to him and it is only made more difficult by the tragedy that seems to follow him around.

While the book does put Harry in a dark place at times (pun intended) it does also have lighter moments, some of which are found through the way J.K. Rowling uses alliteration in names. It only takes a couple of pages to realize this. Salazar Slytherin, Godric Gryffindor, Minerva McGonagall, Bertie Bott, and Zaphod Beeblebrox are just a few examples of the character names that can be found using this technique. That last one might not be hers…

Rowling has an immense talent for naming objects and places with alliteration that make them memorable. I think we can agree Polyjuice Potion is more enjoyable to read than Shapeshifting potion. Also the Womping Willow not only describes what the tree does, but is aesthetically superior to Willow Tree that Beats Up Anything Nearby. I think the names that Rowling chooses for her characters and places really bring another dose of magic to the stories, showing not only how different the wizarding world is from the Muggle world, but how fantastic it is as well.

However, Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is not without its flaws. The plot is extremely similar to that of the first book, which doesn’t necessarily detract from the story but does make it a bit too familiar. Also, the dreaded adverbs are back. I didn’t notice many for the first half of the book, but they came back with a vengeance in the latter half. I would sometimes find as many as five on one page and they would often be one or two sentences away from each other. I know I’m probably knit picking, but it did become distracting as I continued reading.

I also found some pacing issues in that the mystery flows pretty well up until the third act, where revelations suddenly rush forward and we’re at a *Spoiler alert* very quick confrontation where the villain reveals his evil plan and everything Harry got wrong about it before being defeated after Harry is grievously wounded and saved miraculously (sound familiar HP and the Sorcerer’s/Philosopher’s Stone?). At this point, I wonder if being saved at the last second is Harry’s real super power. The ending is also abrupt with all relevant loose endings tied up and a hopeful look toward summer.

I really did enjoy reading Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (it has taken all of my concentration not to “accidentally” type Chamber Pot of Secrets throughout this review, so I feel some applause may be deserved) and think that, as far as sequels go, there are many that are much worse. It is almost a self-contained story in that it doesn’t do much to set up the next book but, as far as I can tell, that is Rowling’s aim. I’m sure there will be a payoff in later books, but as of now, I can say that Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is a fun read that will make you look forward to the next book in the series.

Verdict: 3 of Fawkes’s phoenix feathers out of 5

Recommended for: Anyone, everyone, people of all ages, fans of flying cars, snake whisperers, adventurous youth, bespectacled children with lightning bolt scars, lovers of western mythology, and fans of the first Harry Potter book.

Not recommended for: Tom Riddle, people who don’t like enchanted journals, Ginny Weasley, Draco Malfoy, sequel haters, those who always avoid alliteration, the Dursleys, Nearly Headless Nick, or Mrs. Norris the cat.

8 thoughts on “Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets – Review

  1. In some ways I actually think Chamber of Secrets may be my favorite among the Harry Potter series. Mostly just because of how threatening the antagonist feels. The idea of an enemy that literally appears and disappears, striking down its victims in such a complete way, gives the story real potency. In many ways it makes this one almost read like a type of horror story, where the antagonist is both a mystery and a monster. There’s also the way in which Harry questions his own potential for darkness, another common trope of good horror, fearing the monster within.

    I definitely agree that the resolution is a little “deus ex machina”, but being a young adult fantasy novel, it hardly surprised me.
    There are definitely some stories that bank on the promise that “at the end of the day everything’s going to be okay”.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: Reading Tally for 2016 – Perpetually Past Due

  3. Haha! Loved your review, I wouldn’t recommend it for Gilderoy Lockhart too! too greasy a character. I liked how you’ve recommended it for bespectacled children with lightning bolt scars 😁 yeah👍

    Liked by 1 person

  4. “Zaphod Beeblebrox” – hahaha! For a moment, I was baffled. 🙂
    As usual, good review!
    I did not read the second book so, can’t agree/disagree with your views. The reason why the Harry Potter series is my favorite is because I jumped into the series from Book 4, and I could grasp Harry and the wizarding world’s entire history without having to refer to earlier books. That’s Rowling’s writing prowess.
    “all relevant loose endings tied up” – this is applicable to all the books in this series. She ties up majority of the loose ends of that book by the end of that book. Okay, enough rambling! Looking forward to reviews of the rest of the books in this series so, that I can ramble in your comments’ section. (evil grin) 😀

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Never been a fan of Harry Potter, or YA books in general. Back when I were a lad, you had kids books and adult books, which is why I ended up reading James Herbert when I was 8. I’ve read Divergent, Feed, and a few other YA books, and they never really seem to have any solidity to the worlds they’ve created. Maybe it’s because I remember when I was a kid, and the most fascinating thing for me was trying to understand what the hell it was like being an adult.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s