American Gods – Review

American Gods by Neil Gaiman

Illustrations by Dave McKean

Published in 2001; 2017 Edition by The Folio Society

Pages: 537

Genre: Fantasy, mythology


Disclaimer: This review will be different from the norm in that it is split into two parts: a standard, albeit shorter, book review and a specific review of this Folio Society edition. I am endorsing this product through my own volition and belief in its high quality.

Part I: The Story

“Shadow had done three years in prison.”

American Gods has been in the spotlight quite a bit lately with the recent television adaptation on the Starz network. This review, however, covers the book written by Neil Gaiman, upon which the show is based. American Gods follows the life of ex-convict Shadow Moon after he is released from prison, learns his wife died in a car crash, and meets the mysterious Mr. Wednesday. What follows is a meandering road trip across not only the geography of America, but the cultures and beliefs that came across the sea in the hearts and minds of immigrants.

The premise of American Gods was inspired by the idea that immigrants brought their gods and beliefs with them when they came to America. In the late 20th century, worship of these gods wains and they are forced to scrape a meager existence as taxi drivers, morticians, butchers, and prostitutes in order to keep themselves alive by taking micro-transactions of belief and individual worship from humans.

Times are tough not only because these old gods have lost followers, but they have lost them to the new gods of technology, money, and media. There is a war brewing and Shadow is pulled into the middle when he is recruited by Mr. Wednesday, a strange and powerful god, who offers Shadow a job when he leaves prison. This is a road story about Shadow traveling the United States of America with Mr. Wednesday in order to recruit gods for the coming war.

Throughout this tour of recruitment in the form of an elongated road trip, deities from Norse, Egyptian, Greek, Slavic, and African myths all make appearances as Mr. Wednesday seeks allies for the coming conflict. The references to the true identities of the gods are all oblique, allowing the reader to guess at who they are before being fully revealed. Many of these character’s names allude to their true names *Spoilers follow for those who want to read and guess*: Mr. Nancy (the African spider god, Anansi), Mr. Wednesday (the Norse god Odin), Mr. Ibis (Thoth) and Mr. Jacquel (Anubis), though some easier than others (looking at you, Low-Key Lyesmith).

Though the main story follows Shadow and his immersion into the world of myth and legends, the book is interspersed with stories of other gods and cultural creatures. Piskies and leprechauns from Europe, the ifrit and jinn of Arabia, and voodoo legends from the African tribes all have their tales told between the primary action. These asides and their evidence of the gradual loss of old world beliefs lend credibility to the idea of America being a place that’s was never intended for gods.

American Gods builds toward a final confrontation that could be considered anticlimactic by those not paying attention; seemingly disparate events and characters tie together well in the end and the questions posed in the novel are answered in such a way that is conducive to an appropriate conclusion to the story.

Part II: The Book Itself

1. Frontispiece.jpg

This 2017 Folio Society Edition is an Author’s Preferred Text; what that means is this version has been combed through for typographical, story, spelling, and grammatical errors and has been personally vouched for by Neil Gaiman himself. This isn’t the story in its original published form, but it is the closest version to the author’s vision of what the book could be.

A standout aspect of this edition is the inclusion of illustrations by Dave McKean; a frequent collaborator with Gaiman since 1986, McKean’s eerie and surreal artwork lends itself to the strange and otherworldly tone of American Gods. It is easy to see why these two have worked together so long due to their complementary talents and skill within their respective forms of art.

As the story moves on, the illustrations become more spread out which keeps them from distracting from the narrative and allows them to showcase key scenes. There is a short, eye-opening introduction written by McKean where he describes the process of picking the scenes and how he went about translating Gaiman’s vivid words to represent them in the visual medium.

2. Double Page Spread.jpg
Double-page spread of the carousel

Here are some specifications taken from The Folio Society web page:

  • Bound in cloth blocked with a design by the artist
  • Set in Maxime with Wicked Grit display
  • 560 pages
  • Frontispiece and 11 colour illustrations, including 3 double-page spreads
  • Printed slipcase
  • 10˝ x 6¾˝
3. Back of Slip case.JPG
Spine of the book and one side of the slipcase

American Gods is one of my favorite books for many reasons. The story is intricate, the characters are complex, it focuses around mythology and beliefs, and it showcases some of Gaiman’s best prose writing. It was an easy decision to buy this version of the book when I first heard about it and was well worth the price tag. A lot of care went into the crafting of this Folio Society edition and it was because of this that I bought their edition of Casino Royale as a gift for my father’s birthday. If you are a fan of American Gods, Dave McKean’s art, and Neil Gaiman’s writing (and have the fiscal ability) then this is a must buy.

American Gods - Paperback.JPG
My paperback copy of American Gods.

Verdict: 5 cloth-bound editions out of 5

Recommended for: Fans of Neil Gaiman, mythology enthusiasts, those who enjoy art that is as strange and beautiful as the story it accompanies, and bibliophiles.

Not recommended for: People who don’t like Neil Gaiman, people who aren’t willing to fork over more than $20 for a book (let alone $135), children (some adult language and content is present), or people who don’t like art that is as beautiful as it is strange.

24 thoughts on “American Gods – Review

  1. Reading your review of American Gods it sounds like you’d like Salman Rushdie’s “Two Years, Eight Months and Twenty-Eight Nights.” It isn’t even so much based on the Arabian Nights (as the title might suggest) as it is on Arabian mythology, particularly the ifrit and jinn. It’s set in contemporary NYC and tilts at being a pseudo-reality. Not Rushdie’s best writing by any means but still an amusing story!

    My first Gaiman will probably be the Graveyard Book. I bought it a short while ago and am only waiting to finish one or two other books I’m in before I start it.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. That definitely piques my interest! Thank you for the recommendation!

      I really enjoyed the Graveyard Book and I think it is one of his better stories. Some of his writing falls short for me (if you’re into comics, I highly recommend his Sandman series. It is where he really shines.) but that definitely is one of the highlights. Let me know what you think and thank your for commenting!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: Sunshine Blogger Award #1

  3. Nice review! The book definitely sounds like fun. (Another thing to add to my ever-growing reading list?) This is coming from an uninformed individual, but do you feel like it resembles the spirit of the “Percy Jackson” books, except aimed more at adults?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much! I have only read the first of the Percy Jackson series but I would say that that is a fairly accurate comparison. They both deal with gods living in the U.S. but where Percy Jackson is pulled along his adventures, Shadow really showcases agency and I think has a deeper characterization. This book definitely isn’t for kids, though, because there is some graphic content.

      Liked by 2 people

    1. I am always a little hesitant to recommend American Gods to Gaiman fans who haven’t read it because it is a bit of a departure from a lot of his other work in its length and story; that being said, it is my favorite book of his and I will definitely have to check out The View from the Cheap Seats! Thank you for reading and commenting!


  4. Pingback: On the Subject of Giving, Keeping, Selling, and Buying Books – The Past Due Book Review

  5. Pingback: Mort – Review – The Past Due Book Review

  6. Pingback: On The Subject of The Folio Society – The Past Due Review

  7. Pingback: The View from the Cheap Seats – Review – The Past Due Review

  8. Pingback: I Am Legend – Review – The Past Due Review

  9. Pingback: Reading Tally for 2016 – Perpetually Past Due

  10. Pingback: Reading Tally for 2017 – Perpetually Past Due

  11. Pingback: On the Subject of Giving, Keeping, Selling, and Buying Books – Perpetually Past Due

  12. Pingback: Mort – Review – Perpetually Past Due

  13. Pingback: On the Subject of Revisiting Books – Perpetually Past Due

  14. Pingback: On The Subject of The Folio Society – Perpetually Past Due

  15. Pingback: The View from the Cheap Seats – Review – Perpetually Past Due

  16. Pingback: I Am Legend – Review – Perpetually Past Due

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s